NACDL presents its Judicial Recognition Award to acknowledge judges who demonstrate a continuing dedication to protecting democratic principles and the fundamental rights of individuals within American society.
| 2019 | Judge L. Felipe “Phil” Restrepo | Pennsylvania |
| 2015 | Judge John Gleeson | New York |
| 2010 | Rt. Hon. Beverley McLachlin, P.C. | Ottawa |
| 2010 | Judge Mary Lou Robinson | Texas |
| 2009 | Judge Lewis A. Kaplan | New York |
| 2008 | Judge Morris S. Arnold | Arkansas |
| 2008 | Judge Shira A. Scheindlin | New York |
| 2007 | Judge Boyce F. Martin, Jr. | Kentucky |
| 2006 | Judge William M. Hoeveler | Florida |
| 2005 | Judge Matthew J. Perry, Jr. | South Carolina |
| 2004 | Judge Gilbert S. Merritt | Tennessee |
| 2004 | Judge Thomas A. Wiseman, Jr. | Tennessee |
| 2001 | Judge Nancy Gertner | Massachusetts |
| 1999 | Judge Gerald Kogan | Florida |
| 1998 | Judge William W. Daniel | Georgia |
| 1996 | Judge Patrick F. Kelly | Kansas |
| 1994 | Judge Jack B. Weinstein | New York |
| 1994 | Judge Daniel W. Moylan | Maryland |
| 1994 | Judge Juan G. Burciaga | New Mexico |
| 1992 | Judge Marilyn Hall Patel | California |
| 1992 | Judge Wiliam M. Kelsay | California |
| 1992 | Judge Mary Lupo | Florida |
| 1987 | Judge John L. Kane, Jr. | Colorado |
